Written by AIEvery story here is written by an AI. Tell it what you want and it writes it for you →
AI smut writer →
Erotic Audio Story

Amish Girl's Anal Deflowering

An experienced city lesbian anal-fucks her eager Amish helper with a strap-on.

▶ 10 min listen AI-narrated by Bella Lesbian
▶ Listen to this story
Rate the narration:

Prefer to read it? Open the full story →

Full transcript

The farmhouse sat crooked at the end of a gravel lane, its clapboards peeling in long gray strips, windows cloudy with years of neglect. Adriana had chosen it on purpose after the divorce, packing the last of their city apartment into a rented truck and driving until the sky got bigger and the neighbors farther apart. She wanted quiet. She wanted her daughter away from the bars and the girls and the trouble that had followed Ingrid through every crowded street. Ingrid was nineteen, sharp-mouthed and restless, an experienced lesbian who had been fucking women since the week she turned eighteen and saw no reason to apologize for it. The country felt like exile to her, a punishment dressed up as a fresh start.

Adriana hired help on the third morning. The girl who stepped down from the buggy wore a plain gray dress that reached her calves, a white apron, and a stiff white bonnet that hid every strand of her dark hair except the damp curls at her nape. Her name was Hannah. She was nineteen, the same age as Ingrid, sent from a neighboring Amish farm to paint walls and scrub floors until the old house looked livable. Hannah's hands were already work-rough. Her voice stayed soft. She kept her eyes down whenever Ingrid looked too long.

They started in the parlor. Adriana mixed the pale cream paint, pointed out the worst water stains, and then drove into town for more supplies and a long meeting with the county clerk. She would be gone most of the day. That left Ingrid and Hannah alone with rollers, drop-cloths, and the smell of fresh latex.

Ingrid watched Hannah climb the wooden stepladder. The modest dress pulled tight across a round, heavy ass every time she reached for the high trim. Her waist was small. Her breasts sat modest but full beneath the fabric, nipples faintly visible when she stretched. Sweat darkened the back of her dress between her shoulder blades. Ingrid felt the pull immediately, hot and familiar, the same hunger that had gotten her into every pretty girl's bed back in the city. She stripped off her overshirt and worked in a thin tank top that showed the ink on her collarbone and the easy, unashamed confidence of a woman who knew exactly what she liked.

Hannah hummed a hymn under her breath. Ingrid stood close when she passed the roller, letting her fingers brush Hannah's paint-smeared knuckles. She complimented the way the dress clung when Hannah bent over the baseboards. Hannah stammered a quiet thank-you and kept working, but a flush rose on her pale cheeks and her breathing changed. Ingrid's nipples tightened under the cotton. She imagined peeling that bonnet off, licking the salt from Hannah's neck, teaching that devout little mouth what a woman's cunt tasted like. By the time they broke for water, Ingrid was wet in her panties and Hannah's hands were not quite steady.

The sexual tension thickened the next two days like the paint on the walls. Adriana left again after breakfast, this time for a full day of errands in town, and Ingrid did not wait. She worked in cutoff shorts that rode high on her thighs and a tank top with no bra. Every time Hannah's gaze flickered to the hard points of Ingrid's nipples, Ingrid smiled slow and dirty.

"You keep looking," Ingrid said, dipping her roller. "It's all right. I like it when pretty girls look."

Hannah's ears went red under the bonnet. She concentrated on a corner, but her hips shifted as if she could not get comfortable.

Ingrid stepped in behind her, close enough that her breath touched Hannah's ear. "Your ass looks so round in that dress. Makes me want to get my hands under it. You ever had a girl touch you like that? Soft at first, then greedy?"

Hannah's roller stilled. "I... I should not speak of such things."

"But you're curious." Ingrid's voice dropped, filthy and patient. "I can tell. Your nipples are hard. I bet if I slid my hand up between your legs right now I'd find you soaked through those plain little panties. Lesbian touch feels better than anything you've been taught to want. A mouth on your clit. Fingers spreading you open. Another girl's tongue pushing inside you while you shake."

Hannah made a small, helpless sound. Paint dripped forgotten from her brush. "I have thought about the outside world. At night. Things I am not supposed to want."

"Tell me."

"I get wet," Hannah whispered, shame and heat mixing in her voice. "When you talk. When you stand so close. I have never... with anyone. Not even myself, not properly. But I wake up aching. I want to know what it feels like."

Ingrid's cunt clenched. She turned Hannah by the shoulders, looking straight into those wide, dark eyes. "You want me to show you."

Hannah's throat worked. Then she nodded, once, desperate. "Please. Show me what I have been missing. I am asking. I want it."

Ingrid took her by the wrist and led her upstairs to the half-painted bedroom where a canvas drop-cloth already covered the scuffed floor. Afternoon light came through the uncurtained window in a thick gold bar. Ingrid kicked the door shut with her heel, pulled the bonnet off, and let Hannah's dark hair tumble down. She kissed her hard, tongue pushing past surprised lips until Hannah moaned into it and kissed back, clumsy and hungry. Ingrid's hands found the hooks of the dress, stripping it down Hannah's arms, then the shift, then the plain cotton panties that were already dark with wetness. Hannah stood naked and shivering with want, breasts high and flushed, a neat thatch of dark hair between her thighs, her pink pussy lips glistening.

Ingrid shoved her own shorts and panties down, tank top off, and guided Hannah onto the drop-cloth. She kissed down her throat, sucked a nipple until Hannah arched, then spread those thighs and pushed two fingers straight into the dripping heat. Hannah was tight, soaked, clenching. Ingrid curled her fingers and rubbed her thumb over the swollen clit in tight circles.

"That's it. Fuck my fingers. Let me feel you come."

Hannah's hips jerked. She came with a shocked cry, pussy pulsing around Ingrid's fingers, juices running down onto the paint-spattered cloth. Ingrid kept working her through it, then withdrew her glistening hand. Paint from earlier still stained her knuckles. She scooped more of Hannah's wetness, mixed it with the latex smear, and pressed a paint-stained fingertip against Hannah's tight, virgin asshole.

"This is next," Ingrid said. "I'm going to fuck this untouched ass with my cock."

She reached into her discarded shorts for the thick silicone strap-on she had packed like a secret, already fitted to the harness. She stepped into it, the heavy dildo jutting obscenely from her hips, and slicked it with more of Hannah's come and the paint-stained lube on her fingers. She pushed Hannah onto all fours on the drop-cloth, ass high, face down. Hannah looked back, eyes glassy, and nodded.

"Yes. Please. Take it. I want you to."

Ingrid lined the fat head against that tiny pink hole and pushed. Hannah's ass resisted, then opened, stretching around the thick cock with a wet, filthy sound. Ingrid sank in slow, inch by inch, watching the rim cling and swallow. Hannah gasped, fingers clawing the cloth, then shoved back anyway.

"Deeper. It hurts so good. Don't stop."

Ingrid gripped her hips and started thrusting, the strap-on burying to the hilt in that virgin ass, balls of the harness slapping Hannah's dripping pussy. Paint-smeared fingers dug into Hannah's flesh. She fucked her in long, deep strokes, then shorter and harder, the wet slap of skin filling the half-painted room. Hannah's tits swung. She pushed back onto every thrust, ass rippling, begging loud.

"Harder. Fuck my ass harder. I can take it. Fill me up. Use me."

Ingrid reached under and rubbed Hannah's clit while she pounded her. Hannah came again, ass clamping down on the thick cock, a gush of pussy juice splashing the drop-cloth. Ingrid did not stop. She pulled out, manhandled Hannah around, and sat back on her heels so Hannah could straddle her in reverse cowgirl. Hannah sank down on the strap-on with a broken moan, taking every inch up her freshly fucked ass, then started riding, grinding, Ingrid's hands on her waist.

"That's it. Bounce on it. Show me how much you love getting your virgin hole stretched."

Hannah rode hard, ass cheeks spreading around the base, her own fingers flying over her clit. Ingrid thrust up to meet her, the dildo punching deep. Hannah's head fell back, hair wild, mouth open.

"Deeper—please, Ingrid, ram it deeper—I'm going to come again—your cock is so thick in my ass—"

They came together, messy and loud. Hannah's ass milked the strap-on in rhythmic spasms while her clit pulsed under her fingers. Ingrid ground up through her own orgasm, thighs shaking, watching that pretty Amish ass swallow her cock over and over. Come and lube leaked down onto Ingrid's hips. Hannah kept moving through it, greedy, until her legs gave out.

Hannah collapsed forward onto the drop-cloth, ass still stuffed full, body trembling in aftershocks, pussy twitching, a filthy wet trail leaking from her stretched hole down her thighs. She turned her head, grabbed Ingrid by the hair, and kissed her deep and sloppy, tongue tasting her own juices. "Thank you for splitting my ass open. I will come back tomorrow. We will finish the house. You will fuck this hole again whenever you want." Their hands stayed on each other, lingering, Ingrid's paint-stained fingers still buried in Hannah's messy crack, whispering about the next time, the next room, the next load she would pump into that eager Amish ass. Hannah clenched around the cock still lodged inside her and hissed, "Leave it in and breed my shithole until I can't walk."

Fresh filth, nightly

The best new stories in your inbox every day. Free, 18+, unsubscribe anytime.