Divorced Neighbor's First Taste
Divorced neighbor's eager bartender begs her best friend's experienced stepdad to fuck her.
Carmen had a habit of borrowing things she didn't need. Sugar, mostly. She'd moved into the little rental next door three months after finishing college, poured drinks at O'Malley's four nights a week, and discovered that the fastest route to Dante's kitchen counter ran straight through his divorce's fresh wreckage.
Dante was forty-two, freshly single, and doing his best to pretend he hadn't noticed. His stepdaughter Priya was Carmen's best friend, which made Carmen a fixture at his old life's barbecues and his new life's periphery—and made the swell of her ass in those denim cutoffs a problem he was not equipped to solve. She'd started wearing perfume his ex-wife used to wear. He knew the scent instantly, the first time she leaned over his counter to reach for the sugar bowl. He also knew she knew.
"You always out of sugar on Thursdays?" he asked once, handing over the ceramic jar he'd bought specifically so she'd have something to borrow.
"Always out of something." She was twenty-three and looked at him like he was a menu and she'd already picked her meal.
He told himself it was nothing. He told himself that right up until the sweltering Friday night she knocked twice, fast, and stood on his porch flushed pink from her hairline to the collar of her tank top, no bra, nipples like two thumbs pressing through the cotton.
"Bad date," she said, stepping past him into the kitchen like she owned it. "He was twenty-five and he talked about his crypto portfolio for an hour. I faked a work emergency."
"Rough."
"You want to know what I told my friends I was doing tonight?" She turned around in the middle of his kitchen, backed up until her spine hit the island's edge, and looked at him through her lashes. "I told them I was coming over here. To you. I've been thinking about you since I was old enough to know what I was thinking, Dante. Years. Every time Priya dragged me to some party at your house, I used to go home and get myself off thinking about you."
"Carmen."
"Don't say my name like it's a warning." She crossed the space between them in three steps and pressed herself against his chest, deliberately, dragging her hard nipples against him in a slow arc that made his breath come out in a shake. "Priya's at her mom's until Sunday. Your house is empty. My house is empty. Nobody has to know. Show me what a real man feels like. Please. I've been so good for so long."
He had one thread of restraint left, and she cut it cleanly by sinking to her knees on his kitchen tile, looking up at him with those hungry dark eyes, and whispering, "I want to taste my best friend's stepdad. I've wanted it forever. Pull it out. Let me have it."
Dante hauled her up by the arm before his cock could win the argument, spun her around, and bent her flat over the kitchen island. "You want a real man," he growled, yanking her shorts and panties down to her ankles in one rough pull, "then quit talking and take one."
He dropped to his knees behind her like a man at an altar, spread her cheeks apart with both thumbs, and buried his face in her dripping cunt from behind. She was soaked, had been soaked since the porch, and she screamed when his tongue fucked up into her—actually screamed, loud enough that he was briefly glad for the empty houses on either side. He ate her like a starving man, licking from her clit up through her folds and back, sealing his mouth over her hole and sucking until her thighs shook, then dragging his tongue up to circle her tight little asshole just to hear her make a sound she'd never made on any bad date in her life.
"Oh fuck—Dante—right there—don't stop—" She clawed at the island's surface, cunt gushing over his chin. He slid two thick fingers into her and curled them against that sweet spot while he sucked her clit, and she came apart in under a minute, screaming again, her pussy clenching his fingers so hard it almost hurt.
He stood, wiped his mouth with the back of his hand, and freed his cock. She craned her head around to watch, eyes going wide. "Oh my God, that's—"
"You can take it." He pressed the fat head against her entrance, teased it through her slick folds. "Beg for it."
"Fuck me. Please, please fuck me, I've been such a good girl, I've waited so long—"
He slammed in to the hilt. She shrieked and shoved her hips back to meet him, greedy even as her breath punched out of her. He grabbed a fistful of her hair with one hand, wrapped the other loosely around her throat from behind, and gave her exactly what she'd asked him for—deep, punishing strokes that made her ass ripple and the island's bar stools rattle.
"Harder," she gasped. "Choke me, Daddy, I'm yours, use me—"
He squeezed gently, just enough pressure to make her lightheaded and sloppy, and pounded her standing doggy until her legs gave out, then pulled out, spun her around, and lifted her onto the counter. He shoved her knees up to her shoulders, folded her in half, and drove back into that soaked young cunt in missionary, watching her tits bounce with every thrust, watching her mouth hang open.
"Look at you," he grunted. "Priya's sweet little friend. All grown up and begging for her best friend's stepdad's cock."
"Yes—yes—it's so fucking good—" Her eyes rolled. "I used to hear you and your wife through the wall when I slept over and I'd touch myself thinking it was me—"
Filthy little thing. He fucked her harder, the counter thumping, her heels drumming his back. When he felt her second orgasm building in the clamp of her pussy, he pulled out and fed his cock down her throat instead, holding her head, fucking her mouth while she gagged and drooled, spit running down her chin onto her tits, her eyes watering as she moaned around him like it was the best thing she'd ever tasted.
"Gag on it. Good girl." He pulled back before he blew, dragged her to the counter's edge, and sank home again, balls deep, wrapping her legs over his shoulders. "One more. Come on my cock like the dirty girl you are."
She clawed his back, raking red lines down it, sobbing his name and then, as she tipped over the edge, "Daddy—Daddy, I'm coming—" and her cunt strangled him so tight he lost it, burying himself to the root and flooding her, pulse after pulse of hot cum filling her while he growled into her neck and she writhed under him, taking every drop.
He stayed buried in her, both of them dripping, breathless. She propped herself up on her elbows, reached down between her thighs where his cock was still plugging her full, scooped the cum that leaked out around him onto two fingers, and licked them clean with a satisfied, wicked smile.
"Mmm." She looked up at him, twenty-three and thoroughly ruined on his kitchen island. "Priya goes to her mom's every other weekend, Dante. And I close the bar at two. You're going to leave your back door unlocked, and I'm going to come over and you're going to ruin me again. And again. Every time I want it. That's the deal, right?" She clenched her used little cunt around his half-hard cock and whispered against his mouth, "Because this pussy's yours now, Daddy—and next time I'm letting you finish in my ass."
He was already hard again inside her, and God help him, the back door was unlocked from here on out—because he was never going to get enough of his neighbor's tight, cum-hungry holes.
Rate this story
Something wrong with this story?
Want your own taboo story?
Tell the AI the set-up. It writes it for you in about five minutes. Free.