Family Reunion: Wife's Dad and Father-in-Law
I finally let my wife's dad fuck me raw in the boathouse.
The lake sat bright and still beyond the open boathouse, sun breaking on the water in hard coins of light. Up on the cabin lawn the reunion had settled into its usual noise: grill smoke, a radio, the smack of a game somebody always brought. Benedict had slipped away from all of it. At fifty-two he was the host and Cassidy's father, the man who kept this place standing, and he still looked it. Broad through the shoulders, gray at the temples, muscle laid thick over a frame that had spent decades hauling docks and splitting wood. Sweat darkened the collar of his polo. He stood with one hand on the workbench and listened to the laughter stay where it belonged, up the path.
Lionel came in with two bottles beading cold against his palms. Forty-nine, Danielle's father-in-law, he filled a doorway without trying. Job-site muscle, a close-cut beard gone salt and pepper, jeans sitting low on hips that had no give in them. Those marriages had made them in-laws, thrown together in the same rooms for years. Acquaintances, on paper. In practice they had been stealing looks across picnic tables and letting their banter run a half-step too warm, both of them mature enough to know exactly what they were doing and neither of them, until now, alone long enough to finish it.
"They're buried in the tournament," Lionel said. "Barbecue's covered. You've got time."
Benedict took the bottle, tipped it once, and set it down. One swallow. He wanted his head clear, and it was. "You came looking."
"I came looking." Lionel's gaze moved over the open throat of Benedict's shirt, the heavy chest, the line of his arms. The wanting between them had weight. It sat in the cedar smell and the heat and the quiet slap of water under the dock. Two muscular men who had spent too many summers pretending the charge was only friendship. Benedict felt it low in his gut, and he saw the same answer in the way Lionel did not step back.
They took the bench that faced the water and left the bottles mostly full. Lionel talked about a dock repair from two summers back, and Benedict listened to the low scrape of his voice more than the story. The years sat between them like a dare. Benedict turned, knee brushing Lionel's, and stopped pretending the brush was an accident.
"I've wanted to fuck you," he said. No joke under it. "For a long time. Right here, with the others up on that lawn and you looking at me like you already knew."
Lionel's breath left him short. Heat climbed his throat. He did not look away. "Say it again."
"I want to fuck you." Benedict's hand found Lionel's thigh and stayed there, heavy and sure. "And I want you to fuck me. I've been carrying it since you started standing too close. You feel it."
"I feel it." Lionel's voice had gone rough. He set his bottle aside without drinking. Sober as the man beside him, clear-eyed, he leaned in until their mouths were a decision. "I've wanted your cock in me. I've wanted mine in you. Every August I go home and handle it alone. I'm done handling it alone."
Benedict kissed him. It was not careful. Lionel's mouth opened, hungry, beards scraping, hands already greedy. He kissed back like he had been waiting years for it, tongue sliding deep, one fist in Benedict's shirt. They broke only to breathe and to see they were both in it.
"Lock it," Lionel said.
Benedict threw the bolt. The laughter outside belonged to other people. When he turned, Lionel was pulling his shirt off, chest broad and furred with silver, stomach still hard. Benedict got his hands on him at once. He dragged his palms down that chest, over warm muscle, down to the belt.
"Off."
They stripped each other with no patience left for the distance they had kept in every other room of this reunion. Benedict's polo went over his head. Lionel shoved his pants down with his briefs, and Benedict's cock came up thick and flushed, wet at the tip. A rough, pleased sound, and Lionel's fist wrapped it, stroking once, learning the weight. Benedict got Lionel just as bare. The cock that filled his hand was heavy, veined, hot. He stroked it and watched that hard stomach jump. They kicked free of shoes and denim until both stood naked on the worn boards, muscular and hard and done waiting. Cocks slid together when they kissed again.
"Bench," Lionel said against his mouth. "I want you in me. Now."
"Yeah. Tell me if you need me slower."
"I will. I won't."
Benedict turned him to the sturdy workbench. Lionel bent over it at once, hands flat on worn wood, back flexed, ass up, thick thighs planted. Benedict stepped in behind and spread him. He spit into his palm, slicked his cock, and pressed two wet fingers to that tight hole.
"Yes," Lionel said, pushing back. "Don't tease. Fuck me."
One finger, then two. Benedict crooked them until Lionel's cock jumped and dripped, working him open until the muscle gave, slick and hungry. Lionel rocked onto those fingers with a groan from his chest.
"Enough. Your cock."
Benedict lined up, gripped those hips hard, and pushed. The thick head breached. The stretch pulled a broken sound out of Lionel, and Benedict sank in to the hilt, shaking at how tight and hot he was.
"All right?"
"Move. Hard. I can take you."
He drew back and drove in. The bench jolted. A rough doggy rhythm, hips snapping, skin loud on skin, both hands locked on Lionel's hips so he could haul him back onto every thrust. Deep enough to knock the breath out of him. Lionel's hole gripped on the pull and yielded on the drive, slick with spit and the leak of Benedict's cock. Benedict watched himself disappear into that ass and fucked harder for it, sweat running down his spine, balls drawing tight.
"Like that," Lionel moaned, pushing back greedy. "Don't ease up. Use me."
"You feel so fucking good." Benedict leaned over that broad back and pounded, dominant and steady. Each thrust shoved Lionel forward; each grip dragged him back onto the cock splitting him open. The workbench creaked. Lionel dropped his head, one hand braced, the other fisting his leaking cock, meeting every stroke, ass clenching, thighs shaking when Benedict hit deep.
The grip on Lionel's hips would leave marks and neither of them cared. Benedict used that hold to set the pace, dominant, fucking deep and hard, the head of his cock kissing the spot that made Lionel curse and shove back for more. Sweat slicked the small of Lionel's back. Benedict licked a stripe of it and drove in again, mean and thorough, until the only sounds were the bench, their breathing, and the wet slap of a man getting exactly what he had asked for.
"Harder. Fill me."
Benedict planted his feet and railed him, long strokes that stayed inside the yes Lionel kept giving. Cedar, sweat, and sex thick in the air. He drove in until his own hips stuttered, then ground deep and held.
"Not yet. I want your cock in me. Switch."
Lionel shuddered and nodded. "Wall."
Benedict pulled free. Lionel walked him back into the boards beside the coiled line, kissed him filthy, and slicked himself with a fresh palm of spit. Two fingers pressed into Benedict, steady and knowing, crooking until his cock jumped. Benedict spread and bore down.
"In me. Rail me."
"You've got me." Lionel hooked a thigh up, pinned him with his weight, and pushed in. Slow for the first thick inches, then deeper when Benedict took him. Full. Stuffed. That heavy cock seated deep.
"Move."
Powerful strokes. Hips driving, the wet sound obscene. Lionel pinned him to the wall and fucked him, forearm braced beside his head, the other hand wrapped around Benedict's cock and stroking in time. Deep, rhythmic, every pound of muscle behind it. Benedict fisted Lionel's hair and gripped that flexing ass, pulling him in harder, moaning into his mouth, pushing back as much as the wall allowed.
Lionel's chest crushed to his. Beard scraped jaw. Every stroke landed deep, powerful, the kind that made Benedict's toes curl against the boards and his cock drool over the fist working him. He was being fucked and stroked at once and he chased both, greedy for the fill, for the rough praise in Lionel's breath, for the wall at his back and the man he had wanted for years finally inside him.
"Take it," Lionel growled. "Every inch. Leaking on my fist while I fuck you open."
"Don't stop. Stroke me. I'm close."
Lionel railed him harder, skin slapping skin, fist tight and slick on Benedict's cock, thumb dragging the head. Benedict clenched around him. Lionel's rhythm roughened, thrusts going short and deep, a groan tearing out each time that hole squeezed.
"Come with me. I want to fill you."
"Yes. Come in me."
Lionel slammed in and stayed. His cock pulsed, hot cum flooding Benedict in thick spurts, filling him, and the fist never stopped. Benedict erupted over that hand and his own stomach, stripe after stripe, moaning, hole fluttering around the cock still pumping him full. Lionel stroked him through it, hips jerking with the last of his release, both of them shaking, locked together, sweaty and wrecked, filling and filled, the pleasure rolling until neither of them could do anything but hold on.
They stayed pinned a moment longer, breath tearing, Lionel's cock still inside him, both of them pulsing through the last of it. Then Lionel eased out, slow, and cum slipped warm down Benedict's thigh. They looked at each other, wrecked and grinning, and reached for the rag on the bench hook without quite letting go.
A quick cleanup. Shirts dragged back on, pants hauled up over sweat-damp skin, belts loosely done. The boathouse still smelled like them. Benedict caught Lionel's jaw and kissed him, deep and lingering, unhurried now that the edge had broken. Lionel kissed him back the same way, a hand spread over the small of his back, holding the afterglow a few seconds longer than was wise.
"Next reunion," Lionel said against his mouth. "We find the time again. Boathouse. Or whatever room locks."
"Yeah." Benedict's thumb stroked the beard. "Stolen moments. As many as we can take."
They checked each other once, collars straight, faces ordinary, the new secret sitting hot between them. Then they unbolted the door and walked up toward the grill smoke and the noise, casual as anything, two men rejoining a family afternoon with the taste of each other still on their tongues.
Rate this story
Something wrong with this story?
Want your own gay male story?
Tell the AI the set-up. It writes it for you in about five minutes. Free.