Written by AIEvery story here is written by an AI. Tell it what you want and it writes it for you →
AI smut writer →

Her Best Friend's First Creampie

Best friends share his very first creampie.

8 min read November 20, 2026New

I need to tell you this from the beginning, because I've never confessed it to anyone, not even my roommate, not even my diary. My name is Simone, I'm twenty-two, a senior in college, and for two years I have been quietly, desperately in love with my best friend Andre.

He's twenty-one, a junior, the kind of boy who blushes when a barista spells his name wrong. We met in a poetry workshop sophomore year, back when he still had a long-distance girlfriend he'd been dating since he was eighteen, some girl in Seattle he clung to out of loyalty more than love. I watched him through two years of movie nights and late-night diners and one disastrous trip to the beach where he got sunburned so badly I peeled aloe strips onto his shoulders with my heart hammering. I never said a word. Best friends don't. Best friends smile and swallow it.

Then, three weeks ago, she dumped him. Over video call. He showed up at my apartment door with a pizza and red eyes, and I held him while he cried, and I thought, god help me, this is it, this is the moment I've been waiting for, and I hated myself a little for how the thought lit me up.

So that brings us to Friday night. My apartment, my couch, my terrible quilt, one movie neither of us watched. Andre was slouched against the armrest in a soft gray t-shirt, and we were doing our usual thing—teasing each other, flicking popcorn, him calling me a tyrant for hogging the remote, me calling him a coward for covering his eyes during the horror parts. It was our language. It had always been our language. Except tonight, somewhere between the second act and the third, the teasing got quieter and the looks got longer, and when I flicked a piece of popcorn at his head he caught my hand and held it.

Just held it. On his knee. His thumb moving over my knuckles like he was asking a question he couldn't say out loud.

"Andre," I said. My voice came out lower than I intended.

"I broke up with her before she broke up with me, you know," he said abruptly. "Emotionally, I mean. Months ago. I just didn't know how to name it."

"Name what?"

He looked at our hands. Then at me. "That I've been thinking about someone else. For a really long time."

My whole body went hot. "Someone at your school?"

"Someone on this couch." His ears were crimson. "And I need to tell you something embarrassing, Simone, and if you laugh I will actually die."

"I won't laugh."

"I've never done it." He swallowed. "Sex. Any of it. Seattle girl and I were waiting, and then we weren't anything at all. And I'm twenty-one and I've never—" He laughed, shaky. "I wanted my first time to be with someone I trust. Completely. And there's only one person in the world I trust like that."

The movie was still playing. I couldn't have told you a single frame of it. My heart was so loud I was sure he could hear it.

"Andre," I said, "look at me." He did. Those brown eyes, terrified and hopeful. "I've thought about this. About being your first. I've thought about it a lot more than a best friend should."

His mouth opened. Closed. "You have?"

"God, yes. For two years." It was out. My confession, finally loose in the air between us. "You have no idea how many nights I—"

"Tell me," he whispered.

I moved closer, close enough to feel his breath. "I've fantasized about it. About you. About being the one who takes your virginity. I'd lie awake thinking about what your face would look like."

The sound he made was almost a groan. And then we were kissing.

I don't know who leaned in first. I think it was both of us, gravity finally winning after two years. His mouth was soft and clumsy and perfect, and I made a sound into him I'd been hiding since sophomore year. His hands hovered at my waist like he was afraid to touch me, so I grabbed them and put them on me, and he groaned, and I felt his fingers learn the shape of me through my shirt.

"Is this okay?" he breathed against my lips.

"It is so okay. Andre, touch me. I've wanted this for so long."

His hands grew braver, sliding up my back, down over my ass, and I straddled his lap because I couldn't stand the distance anymore. He was hard underneath me—I felt him through his sweatpants, long and hot, and I rolled my hips and he gasped like I'd wounded him.

"Simone—"

"I know," I whispered. "I know, baby. I've got you."

We kissed and kissed, my fingers in his dark hair, his lips finding my throat, and when I tugged my shirt off over my head he made this broken noise at the sight of my bare chest. I wasn't wearing a bra. I never wore one for movie night, and suddenly I understood I'd maybe been dressing for him all along.

"You're staring," I teased, breathless.

"You're perfect." He said it like a fact, like gravity. His hands came up, cupping me, his thumbs circling my nipples until I whimpered. He was a fast learner, my shy best friend. He learned my gasps like a new language.

His mouth followed his hands, hot and eager, and I arched into him, grinding against his lap, beyond done pretending. Then he pulled back, forehead against mine, both of us panting.

"Simone." His voice cracked. "I want—I want to finish inside you. My first time, I want to—"

"I know what you want," I whispered, thrilled to my bones. "You want me to take your virginity all the way. You want to give me your first creampie."

He shuddered so hard I felt it. "God. Yes. Please. Is that—can we—"

"Andre." I took his face in my hands. "I want it. I've wanted it. I'm on the pill and I'm clean and I want you to come inside me so badly I can't see straight. Yes."

He made a sound like a prayer.

I led him to my bedroom by the hand, my shy genius boy, and pushed him gently onto the bed. I stripped him slowly—shirt first, kissing down his chest, his stomach jumping under my mouth—then his sweatpants, and he was gorgeous, flushed and hard and leaking already, and I'd barely wrapped my hand around him before he grabbed my wrist.

"I'll—too fast," he panted. "You touch me and I'll be gone."

"Later," I promised. "Tonight you're going to be inside me. But first—"

I sheathed him with a condom-free touch of my mouth, just enough to make him curse, then reached into my nightstand and back away, deciding I wanted him bare and he wanted it too—I'd told him I was safe, he'd told me he'd never been with anyone, and we both wanted skin. I took him in my mouth once more, slow and filthy, just to hear him whimper, and then I crawled up his body and rose over him.

"Watch," I told him.

He watched. His eyes went between us, wide and reverent, as I reached down and guided the head of his cock to my entrance, already soaked. I sank down inch by inch, taking my time, savoring the way his jaw went slack.

"Oh my god," he whispered. "Oh my god, Simone."

"Your first pussy," I said, wicked, and sank fully down. We both groaned. He filled me perfectly, thick enough that I had to adjust, hot and throbbing inside me. His hands found my hips and gripped like I was the only solid thing in the world.

"Move," he begged. "Please, move, I need—"

I moved. Slow at first, rolling my hips, braced on his chest, watching him watch himself disappear into me over and over. His face was a revelation—pure stunned bliss, his lips parted, his eyes flicking between my breasts bouncing softly and the place where we joined.

"That's it," I praised, clenching around him deliberately. "Feel me? Feel how I'm squeezing your virgin cock?"

"I'm not going to last," he choked. "It's so good, it's so—Simone—"

"Then let me ride you," I whispered. "You lasted long enough to be proud of, baby. Now come here."

I rolled us, and he landed between my thighs, wide-eyed, still buried deep, and I wrapped my legs around him.

"Missionary," I said against his mouth. "Fuck me. Don't be gentle anymore. I want you desperate."

He lost it. He thrust, clumsy and deep and hungry, and I met him, pulling him in with my heels, our bodies slapping together, my nails raking his back. He was moaning openly now, no shyness left, filth spilling out of my sweet best friend like a dam breaking.

"You feel so good—so wet—god, Simone, I've imagined this—"

"Me too, baby. Every night. You inside me, just like this—"

"I'm close," he gasped, hips stuttering. "I'm so close, where do you want—"

"Inside me," I demanded, dragging him down, mouth at his ear. "You asked for it, now give it to me. I want your first load, Andre. I want you to fill this pussy up and make it yours. Come inside me. Come inside me now."

He slammed deep one final time and shuddered apart, groaning my name into my neck, and I felt it—hot pulse after pulse of him emptying inside me, and feeling him lose it, feeling my shy boy pour his first-ever release bare into me, sent me over too. My orgasm crashed through me, my whole body clenching around him, milking him, and I sobbed his name while he kept throbbing, kept pumping, until we were both shaking and spent.

We lay there, tangled, his heart slamming against mine, his cock still twitching inside me. He lifted his head and kissed me—tender now, soft, nothing like the desperate boy of a minute ago.

"That was," he breathed, "I don't have words. You're a poet's best friend, tell me what that was."

I laughed, breathless, and clenched around him just to feel him jump. "That was your first creampie, Andre. It's still inside me."

He kissed me again, deeper. "It was perfect. You're perfect. I can't believe I waited and it was you. It was always going to be you."

We stayed like that, him softening inside me, me holding every drop as long as I could, until eventually he slipped out and I felt the slow warm leak of him, and we laughed, giddy, and he pulled me into his chest and traced my spine.

"So," he murmured. "Again?"

"So many times," I promised. "Practice makes perfect, and I intend to make you an expert."

He fell asleep smiling. I lay awake a while longer, his release still trickling warm down my thigh, thinking that after two years of wanting my best friend, I'd finally confessed everything—and so had he, in every way a man can.

I never told him about the second pulse I felt that night, hours later, when he stirred half-asleep against my hip and slid back inside me—but that's next Friday's confession.

And this time, I won't pull away.

Rate this story

★★★★★
Thanks for rating
Something wrong with this story?
Ask the writer

Want your own first time story?

Tell the AI the set-up. It writes it for you in about five minutes. Free.

Adults only · no real people · your request is never shown, only your credit name
Tagged creampie cowgirl missionary virgin dirty-talk

Fresh filth, nightly

The best new stories in your inbox every day. Free, 18+, unsubscribe anytime.