Written by AIEvery story here is written by an AI. Tell it what you want and it writes it for you →
AI smut writer →

Their Shared Girl: The Boy Sandwich

I couldn't choose between my two best friends so I made them share me.

9 min read November 16, 2026New

The apartment was too small for three people who had stopped being only friends. Camila, nineteen, confident and blunt as any tomboy who had spent her life winning games instead of waiting to be chosen, had been inseparable from Errol and Felix since they were kids. Nothing about those years had been sexual. They had just been a unit, and when college started they refused to split. Now the three of them shared a small off-campus apartment while they attended the same college, and the close quarters had turned that old closeness into something none of them could ignore.

Errol was twenty, broad through the chest, quiet until he wasn't. Felix was twenty too, leaner, faster with a grin that had started sticking on Camila's mouth and her ass. Both of them wanted her. Exclusively. They had each said it in the last month, separate conversations in the kitchen after class, careful and serious. Camila had looked each boy in the eye and given the same answer. She couldn't choose. She didn't want to. The want had started here, after they were all adults, in this apartment, in the way Errol watched her cross the living room in cutoffs and the way Felix went hard in his sweatpants when she came out of the shower wrapped in a towel. She wanted both of those reactions. She was not going to solve the tension by throwing one of them out of her life.

Two bedrooms had been a polite lie. Someone always ended up on the couch because a closed door felt like a decision she refused to make. She caught herself listening to them jerk off at night and pressing her own hand between her legs, furious that she was supposed to pick a favorite when her body wanted the set. Shirts came off after practice and stayed off. Camila did homework at the kitchen table in panties and a team tee and pretended not to notice two hard cocks shifting under the table. Errol started offering to spot her when she did pushups on the living room floor, his hands lingering at her hips. Felix cooked dinner shirtless and let her steal bites off his fork, close enough that she could smell soap and sweat on his throat. The apartment hummed. Somebody was going to break, and Camila already knew it would be her, on her terms.

The student party did not fix anything. They went because their classmates were going, and they went sober. Camila had said it before they left: no drinks, no fuzzy heads, she wanted to remember every second if the night turned into something. Errol and Felix had agreed. On the dance floor the three of them stopped pretending the apartment wasn't already halfway to a bed. Errol pulled her back against his chest. Felix faced her, one hand on her waist, the other sliding to the bare strip of skin above her jeans and staying there. They danced close, bodies locked, her ass grinding Errol's cock through his pants while Felix's thigh pressed between hers. Lingering touches. Errol's mouth at her ear, not quite a kiss. Felix's thumb stroking her hipbone until she was wet in her panties and furious at the music for being in the way.

They left before the party thinned. The walk home was quiet and electric. Cool night air did nothing for the heat under Camila's skin. By the time she unlocked the apartment door, both boys were hard, and she was done letting that fact live in separate rooms.

She kicked the door shut and turned on them.

"I'm not choosing," she said. Her voice didn't shake. "I want both of you. Equally. I don't want a favorite and I don't want one of you being decent and stepping back. I want to be the meat in a boy sandwich. Tonight. Our first time. All three of us."

Errol's jaw flexed. "Both of us. Together."

"That's the offer." She looked at Felix. "You want it or you don't."

Felix didn't blink. "I want it. I've wanted you since we moved in. If having him there is how I get you, I want him there."

"I want you," Errol said. The words came out low and sure. "I want this. I need to hear you say you're sure."

"I'm sure." Camila stepped in and set a palm on each of their chests. Hearts kicking. Hers too. "Nobody's drunk. Nobody's guessing. Any of us can stop, any time, no punishment. But if we start, I want the whole crash course. Mouths. My pussy. My ass. Sharing. You take turns and you take me together. Clear?"

"Clear," Errol said.

"Clear," Felix said, already reaching for the hem of his shirt.

In the hall she stopped them once more, because she wanted the yes in the light, not just in the heat. "Last check. Errol, you want my pussy and my ass and his cock in the same bed. Felix, same question. Say it."

Errol's hands were already on his belt. "I want all of that. I want you between us."

"I want to share you," Felix said. "And I want you to use us until you can't talk."

She caught their wrists and pulled them toward the bigger bedroom, the one with the bed that could hold three if they stopped being polite about space. "Then get in there," she said. "And get those pants off. I've been staring at your cocks through fabric for weeks. Tonight I use them."

In the bedroom the lamp was already on. Camila yanked her shirt over her head and shoved her jeans down. No bra. Cotton panties soaked through at the crotch. She hooked them off and stood naked between them, and both boys stared like they had been waiting all semester for the order she gave next.

"Clothes off. Now."

Belts hit the floor. Errol's cock sprang out thick and heavy, the head already wet. Felix's was longer, curved, flushed dark. Camila dropped to her knees on the rug, one hand wrapping each of them, and looked up with pure hunger.

"Crash course starts with my mouth," she said. "First time for all of us. Tell me what you like. I want to learn both cocks."

She took Errol first, lips stretching around the thick head, tongue on the underside, sinking until her fist met her mouth. She pulled off wet and turned to Felix, letting the curve of him bump her throat while she stroked Errol slick with her other hand. They took turns bending to kiss her between sucks, tasting salt and each other, and she moaned into those kisses. She sucked them until both cocks shone and twitched, then wiped her mouth and climbed onto the bed.

"On my back," she said. "Errol, missionary. My pussy. Felix, get behind my hips and take my ass. Fingers, then cock. Slow until I tell you to fuck."

She lay back and spread her thighs. Errol settled between them, lined his thick cock up, and pushed into her pussy in one long missionary stroke that made her gasp and grab his shoulders. He filled her deep, chest to her chest, and held there while she breathed through the stretch of her first time. She hooked her knees up. "Felix. Now. Open my ass and get in. I want the sandwich."

Felix spat into his palm, worked two fingers into her ass while Errol stayed buried in her cunt, and the double pressure dragged a broken sound out of her. She nodded, breathless. "Cock. Both holes. Do it."

Felix pressed the head of his cock to her ass from behind the cradle of her raised legs and pushed. The ring gave. He sank in inch by inch until she was pinned tight between them, meat in the middle, pussy full of Errol's missionary thrusts and ass full of Felix, stuffed so hard she could feel them against each other through her.

"Move," she said. "Both of you. Don't you dare be gentle now."

Errol fucked her pussy in short, deep strokes, missionary and relentless, his mouth on her throat. Felix worked her ass in longer pulls, one hand spreading her, the other braced on the mattress. They found a rhythm, one withdrawing while the other drove in, then both slamming home together until she was shaking and clawing at Errol's back. The orgasm hit her hard. She clenched around both cocks and came loud, telling them to keep fucking her through it.

They swapped without leaving the bed. Felix took Errol's place between her thighs and sank into her pussy while Errol moved behind her hips and pushed into her ass, thicker, stretching her open all over again. She came a second time with Errol buried in her ass and Felix fucking her cunt, drooling, swearing, demanding they switch holes again.

"Edge of the bed," she panted. "Spit-roast me. Cock in my throat while one of you wrecks me from behind."

They hauled her to the edge. Felix fed his slick cock into her mouth while Errol fucked her pussy, then spat on her hole and pushed into her ass. She gagged and moaned and reached back to keep him deep. They switched ends. Errol filled her throat until spit ran down her chin. Felix took her pussy, then her ass, then her pussy again, telling her how good she looked stuffed at both ends. She answered filthy and clear: harder, don't stop, share me.

They put her on her side for another double. Errol slid into her pussy. Felix pressed into her ass. Their cocks rubbed through her while they kissed her mouth, passing her between them. She stroked whichever cock wasn't inside her when they traded holes, sucked them clean, and sent them back in. Vaginal, anal, oral, round after round, their hands greedy on her tits and hips, and every rough question got the same answer: yes, deeper, both of you.

Errol came first, buried in her pussy, groaning her name. Felix pulled out of her ass and she took his cum on her tongue, swallowing while she held his eyes. She got them hard again with her mouth and her fists and took Felix in her ass while Errol fucked her throat until she drooled. She flipped, demanded Errol in her ass and Felix in her pussy, and rode that double until they broke. Errol finished deep in her ass. Felix came in her cunt, hot and thick, and Camila came with them, stuffed and used exactly the way she had ordered.

After the last orgasm they were spent and glistening, cum sliding out of Camila's pussy and ass, her mouth still tasting like both of them. The shower was practical and dirty. She stood between them under the spray and made them wash her holes with their fingers, then stroked both cocks until they thickened again against her hips. "Not yet," she said. "Save it for the bed. One bed. We're done pretending we need two rooms."

They collapsed into the bigger bed naked, skin still damp, the second bedroom already abandoned. It stayed that way. From that night the single room was their playground, and it saw action every time one of them got hard. Mornings started with Camila on her knees sucking them both before class. Nights ended with her stuffed full, pussy and ass, while they took turns coming in her and on her. The empty room across the hall collected dust. Theirs collected sweat, cum, and the sound of her telling them to fuck her harder.

She rolled onto her stomach, ass up, hole still open and shining, and looked back at both of them. "Fill me again before breakfast. Both holes. I want your cocks in me until I'm dripping down my thighs in the hallway."

Rate this story

★★★★★
Thanks for rating
Something wrong with this story?
Ask the writer

Want your own group sex story?

Tell the AI the set-up. It writes it for you in about five minutes. Free.

Adults only · no real people · your request is never shown, only your credit name
Tagged threesome double-penetration anal creampie spitroast

Fresh filth, nightly

The best new stories in your inbox every day. Free, 18+, unsubscribe anytime.