Their TomBoy Sandwich
Three best friends finally snap and double-team their shared tomboy.
The apartment was too small for the kind of want that had grown up between them, and all three of them knew it. Gareth was nineteen. Wesley was nineteen. Giselle was nineteen. They had been best friends since kindergarten, a single stubborn unit through every year after, but none of that old loyalty had been about sex. The hunger was newer. It had started the summer they turned eighteen, when Giselle's laugh started landing low in Gareth's stomach and Wesley caught himself staring at the line of her throat, and it had only gotten worse once they were college freshmen sharing a cramped off-campus apartment.
Two bedrooms. One bathroom. A couch that forced knees to touch. Giselle was the tomboy in the middle of it, choppy dark hair, flannel, jeans with a rip at the knee, shoulders strong from years of keeping up with both boys. She swore like them and ate like them, and lately she slept in thin tanks that did nothing to hide the small, high shape of her breasts. She loved both of them. She had loved them as friends for as long as memory reached, and she had wanted them, specifically and shamelessly, only since she was old enough to want anyone that way. She would not choose. Choosing Gareth meant losing Wesley. Choosing Wesley meant losing Gareth. She refused to crack the only home she trusted.
Close quarters turned the refusal into a daily ache. Gareth, broad through the chest, quiet, with careful hands and a low voice, watched her mouth when she talked. Wesley, lean and quick, all restless energy and a crooked grin, went silent when she stretched and her shirt climbed her ribs. They had begun to snap at each other over who walked her to class, over who got the cushion beside her, over nothing that mattered and everything that did. The tension had a temperature. It lived in the hallway, in the shared bathroom steam, in the way all three of them pretended the mornings were ordinary.
Tonight they had walked home from a campus party sober, the music still in their bones and nobody's judgment blurred by a single drink. On the dance floor both boys had held her like they were staking a claim they were not allowed to finish. Gareth's palm had rested warm at the small of her back. Wesley's fingers had curved over her hip and stayed there through a whole song. She had let them. She had wanted more than letting. Under the one lamp in the living room, jacket still on, she looked at the two young men she could not split apart and felt the decision settle, clean and certain, behind her ribs.
She dropped the jacket over the chair and faced them both. "I'm not picking," she said. Her voice did not shake. "I need you to hear that before anything else. I love you. Both of you. The friend part is old. The wanting started after we turned eighteen, and living in this apartment has made it so I can't sleep. If I take Gareth, I lose you, Wesley. If I take Wesley, I lose you, Gareth. I won't do either."
Gareth sat forward on the couch, elbows on his knees, eyes steady on her face. Wesley stood near the window with one hand in his pocket, the pulse jumping at his throat. Neither of them spoke.
Giselle pulled the flannel open. Under it she wore a thin tank and nothing else on top, nipples already drawn tight against the cotton. "So I'm taking it in hand tonight. I want to be the meat in your sandwich. Both of you. At the same time. I want it to be our first time, all three of us, and I want a crash course. Your cocks in my mouth. In my pussy. In my ass, if we can make that work and if you both still want me when I'm asking for it out loud. I'm sober. I'm not joking. If either of you doesn't want this, say no, and we stop, and tomorrow we are still us. If you both want it, come here and show me."
For a second the room held its breath. Then Gareth stood, and Wesley crossed the carpet, and they reached her together.
"Yes," Gareth said, rough and low. "I've wanted you since the week we moved in. Yes."
"Same," Wesley said, and his grin had gone unsteady. "Since we were eighteen and I finally let myself look. I want this. I want you. I want him here too, if that's what keeps you."
Their mouths were eager, almost clumsy with how long they had waited, and their hands roamed like they were afraid the yes might vanish.
She kissed Gareth first. His mouth was warm, then hungry, and Wesley's lips found the side of her throat. His palm slid up to cup her breast through the tank. Gareth's hands settled at her waist, thumbs stroking bare skin above her jeans. She moaned and reached back, hauling Wesley flush against her. He was hard. So was Gareth, thick against her belly. The proof of both of them at once made her cunt clench around nothing.
"Touch me," she said. "I want your hands everywhere."
They obeyed. Wesley dragged the tank up. Cool air hit her breasts, then his mouth on one nipple while Gareth rolled the other until she gasped. Wesley worked her jeans open and slid his hand over her panties, pressing where she was soaked. She rocked into it. Gareth's fingers joined, and she laughed once, breathless, at how fast the awkwardness burned off.
"Bedroom," she managed. "The big one."
They stumbled down the hall, kissing, stripping. By the largest bedroom she was in panties, the boys in boxer briefs, cocks straining, eyes bright. Wesley knelt and peeled her panties down. Gareth kissed her deeper. "Still yes?" she asked. "Still yes," they said together, hands already roaming her thighs, her ass, her hair.
Giselle dropped to her knees on the rug. She hooked her fingers in both waistbands and drew the boxer briefs down together, and then she had them, Gareth thick and flushed, Wesley a little longer, both hard, both hers. She had never done this. None of them had. The wanting made her brave.
"Crash course," she said, and wrapped a hand around each cock. "Tell me if I do it wrong. Tell me what feels good. Don't be polite."
She took Gareth into her mouth first. The weight of him on her tongue was shocking and perfect, salt and heat, the blunt head nudging her palate. She hollowed her cheeks and sank as far as she could, which was not far, and Gareth's hand landed in her hair with a groan that sounded wrecked. Her other hand stroked Wesley, learning the slide of skin over hardness, the way he twitched when her thumb passed the ridge. Spit slicked her fist. She pulled off Gareth with a wet sound, breathed, and turned to Wesley, swallowing him down while her soaked hand pumped Gareth. Wesley cursed, hips jerking, and she pinned his thigh with her free elbow so he wouldn't choke her.
"Switch," she said, voice rough, and did it again. She sucked one and stroked the other until her jaw ached and both boys were panting, leaking onto her tongue. She looked up with her lips stretched and her chin wet, and the sight nearly ended Wesley on the spot.
"Not yet," Gareth managed. "Bed. I need to be inside her. Wesley, get on the mattress. She can keep you in her mouth."
They moved. Wesley sat against the headboard and she crawled up to kiss him, then swung a leg over and sank onto his cock in one slow drop. The stretch punched a cry out of her. Full. Hot. Too much and exactly enough. Her first time, and she took it with her forehead against his, breathing through the burn until it melted into a deep ache.
"Okay?" Wesley asked, hands gentle on her hips even while his cock throbbed inside her.
"Okay," she said. "Move. God, move."
He thrust up, shallow at first, then deeper, and she rode him, small breasts bouncing, nails in his shoulders. Gareth knelt beside them, and she turned her head and took him back into her mouth, sucking in time with Wesley's hips. The angle was messy. Spit ran down her chin onto Wesley's chest. She didn't care. Every thrust shoved her onto Gareth's cock and every suck made Wesley groan under her. She came like that, sudden and bright, cunt clenching around Wesley, moaning around Gareth, shaking so hard Wesley had to hold her up.
"My turn in her," Gareth said, voice shot. "Wesley, don't finish. Not yet."
They shifted. Gareth laid her on her back and pushed into her soaked pussy in one long stroke that made her arch. He was thicker, a sweet blunt pressure, her heels digging into his back. Wesley knelt by her shoulder and she sucked him, tasting herself, while Gareth fucked her in deep grinding rolls. The bed knocked the wall. She came again, thighs trembling, crying out around Wesley's cock.
"Doggy," she gasped when she could speak. "I want to suck whoever isn't in me. Don't stop. Please don't stop."
Gareth pulled out, turned her onto her hands and knees, and sank into her from behind. The angle hit something that made her vision spark. She dropped to her elbows and Wesley fed his cock between her lips. Gareth's hips slapped her ass, one hand in her short hair. They switched without fully stopping, Wesley sliding into her cunt while Gareth took her mouth, and the sharing felt like a third set of hands. She dripped down her thighs. The room smelled like sex.
"I want both," she said, pulling off Gareth's cock, voice wrecked and sure. "At the same time. Wesley in my ass. Gareth in my pussy. I want to be airtight. I want the sandwich. If it hurts wrong, I'll say stop, and you stop. Lube's in the drawer. I bought it last week because I already knew I was going to ask."
Wesley's hands shook as he found the bottle. Gareth stayed buried in her cunt, barely moving, kissing her spine while Wesley slicked his fingers and pressed one, then two, into her ass. The intrusion burned, then opened, strange and overwhelming beside the fullness already in her pussy. She breathed. She pushed back. "More. I'm good. I'm so good. Put it in."
Wesley lined up and breached her ass slowly, inch by inch, while Gareth held still and stroked her clit so the pleasure had somewhere to go. She sobbed into the pillow from the sheer size of being taken in both holes by the boys she loved. When Wesley was seated, all three of them froze, shaking.
"Move," she begged. "Fuck me. Both of you. Make me the meat. I want it."
They found a rhythm. Gareth withdrew as Wesley pushed in, then they stopped alternating and pounded her together, sweaty, groaning, a hot airtight sandwich on the ruined sheets. Her body shook between them. Every thrust shoved a moan out of her. Wesley's mouth was on her shoulder, praising her in a broken voice. She came so hard her vision whited out, cunt and ass fluttering around both cocks, and the clench dragged Gareth over with her. He buried himself and came, thick pulses flooding her pussy. Wesley lasted three more thrusts and spilled in her ass, arms locked around her waist.
They stayed stuffed inside her, kissing whatever skin they could reach. When the shaking faded, Giselle laughed, hoarse, and pulled them into another round before anyone could get shy. She sucked them hard again, then rode Gareth while Wesley took her ass a second time, slower, until she came crying and they followed, filling her until she dripped from both holes and smiled like she had won.
Sweaty and satisfied, they lay in a tangle on the largest bed, Giselle curled between her two boys with Gareth's arm heavy over her waist and Wesley's breath warm at the back of her neck. The smaller bedroom down the hall already felt like a spare room none of them would use. "We only need this one," she said, voice hoarse and happy. "Move your stuff in tomorrow. I'm not sleeping anywhere you aren't, either of you."
They agreed without arguing. The old tension was gone. The friendship had sealed itself into a three-way they all wanted, no choosing, no losing, and this room would see constant action every night she curled between them.
Giselle smiled into the dark, already scheming. Morning, before class, she would wake them with her mouth on one cock and her hand on the other, then climb onto Gareth and tell Wesley to take her ass again while she was still soft and open from tonight. Oral, vaginal, anal, double-stuffed, every combination, until the sheets had to be changed twice a week and the apartment only had one bedroom that mattered. She pressed back against Wesley and forward into Gareth, already planning the first thrust of tomorrow, and closed her eyes on the want.
Rate this story
Something wrong with this story?
Want your own group sex story?
Tell the AI the set-up. It writes it for you in about five minutes. Free.