Best First Time Sex Stories
The most-read first time sex stories on the site — ranked by what readers actually pick. Browse all First Time stories →
Every story we've published, in one quiet list. New ones land at midnight.
Stepbrother's Gentle First-Time Virgin Seduction
Stepbrother gently takes his 19-year-old virgin sister's first time.
His Wife's One-Night Hall Pass Virgin
A married man takes a shy 19-year-old virgin's first time on his wife's one-night hall pass.
The Lifeguard’s Vinyl Virgin
Shy 19-year-old virgin Cassie loses her cherry to the hot lifeguard on vinyl pool floats.
Reunited Long-Distance Virgins: Our First Night on the Houseboat
Two nervous 19-year-old virgins finally fuck for the first time on a houseboat.
Darkroom Friends: Our First Forbidden Touch
Two virgin best friends lose their virginity together in a pitch-black college darkroom.
The Widow's Midnight Museum Virgin
A lonely virgin widow finally gets fucked hard by a donor in her museum's erotica wing.
The Carpenter's Rooftop Virgin
A shy 19-year-old virgin hires a hot carpenter and loses her virginity on the rooftop.
Reunited Virgins: First Clay-Smeared Surrender
Childhood best friends, both 19-year-old virgins, finally fuck for the first time in slippery clay.
Shy Virgin Stepsister's Consensual First Surrender
Shy virgin stepsister surrenders consensually to stepbro's cock for her first time.
Virgin Stepsister's Eager First-Time Surrender
Virgin stepsister begs hunky stepbrother to pop her eager cherry in a wild first fuck.
Stepbrother's Tender First Time Awakening
Shy virgin stepbro walks in on stepsis masturbating and loses his V-card tenderly.
Virgin Stepsister's Shy Awakening Seduction
Shy virgin stepsister loses it consensually to her horny stepbro in a steamy first-time ride.
The Photographer's Late-Night Laundromat Virgin
A shy 22-year-old virgin gets her first wild fuck from a hot photographer at 2 a.m. in a laundromat.
Her First Taste at the Festival
Lila gives her first sloppy blowjob then gets fucked hard at the music festival.
Karaoke Virgin & The Florist's Midnight Lesson
A shy 19-year-old virgin florist gets his first blowjob and hot fuck from a bold 28-year-old singer in his shop.