Best First Time Sex Stories
The most-read first time sex stories on the site — ranked by what readers actually pick. Browse all First Time stories →
Cassidy seduces her eager virgin neighbor Roman for his very first time.
Two virgin best friends lose their virginity together in a pitch-black college darkroom.
My petite wife eagerly lets our neighbor stretch her with his first enormous 14-inch BBC.
Divorced neighbor Everett takes eager virgin Carmen's first time after the wedding afterparty.
Neighbor asks divorced handyman to watch his daughter for two weeks. She wants him instead.
Sophie watches her husband as Marco gives her first cock.
The shy virgin next door finally begs her neighbor to take her first.
Virgin city girl Marisol loses her cherry to stepbrother Emmett on his farm.
Roxanne, a virgin office assistant, gets her first raw fucking from the hot maintenance guy on the rooftop pool.
Shy Gwen gets her first raw fucking from the hot divorced horse trainer next door.
I brought my virgin coworker home so my husband could fuck her while I watched.
A shy virgin gets his aching, cum-packed balls drained by two eager older neighbors for his first time.
Estelle eagerly sucks and strokes her first massive cock on a hot first date with Reid.
Cruise cougar seduces virgin college freshman.
Best friends Renata and Errol fuck on a rooftop after a truth-or-dare bet takes her virginity.
River gets their first real cock—gently fucked and filled while girlfriend Noelle watches and coaches every moment.
A man finally gives in and deflowers his eager stepdaughter's virgin pussy.
Virgin bride offers her shaved, exposed pussy in crotchless wedding lingerie.
I let a stranger's huge black cock stretch and fill me for the first time.
A nervous virgin books his first sensual massage with a masseuse and ends up coming inside her.
Bianca and her best friend Silas get trapped on a yacht during a storm and eagerly share their first time together.
A married man takes a shy virgin's first time on his wife's one-night hall pass.
I locked myself out in just a T-shirt and begged my hot older neighbor to let me in.
Virgin pool assistant finally claims her eager freshman.
Shy neighbor asks to see her first cock and gives detailed jerk-off instructions.
She offers the eager freshman his very first blowjob.
His neighbor gives the eager virgin his first hot fuck at 4AM.